iPhone Day!
Yesterday, I woke up at 6AM morning to head over to the Apple Store at Pioneer Place in Portland, OR. It was “iPhone Day” after all and there was a 128GB silver iPhone 6 Plus with my name on it somewhere in that store. Fortunately, I successfully preordered mine last Friday and somehow managed to be the very first person in the Reservations line, whereas the line for the day-of purchasers literally wrapped around the entire city block. But based on the global news reporting on this launch, no one should be surprised.
The Face Off Details
Now, there is no shortage of reviews, Op-ed pieces, and social medial posts covering the iPhone 6 and how it is either better or worse than various other Android counterparts. For the most part, juxtaposing phones and opining about who copied who and which OS is better really makes my eyes glaze over. However, I was extremely curious as to how the iPhone 6 Plus compared with one of its closest Android counterparts, the OnePlus One, in a very particular area. I think it’s safe to say that the one place where the iPhone has consistently outperformed just about every other competitor is with its camera and I was eager to see how the new iPhone 6 Plus stacked up against the OnePlus One in what I consider to be the Everyday Shooting Scenario.
In essence, I wanted to see how the cameras on each phone performs in one of the most common environments: during midday with blue skies and a big, bright ball of Sun. On top of that, because the iPhone 6 Plus defaulted to having Auto HDR turned on, I turned on the Auto HDR function of the Google Camera app that I used, as well. And so, during lunch yesterday, I took my dog Kodak to ‘Happyland’ aka Thousand Acres Dog Park near Troutdale, OR. For this face off, I only used the rear camera and left every setting untouched. The only intervention I made was to “touch-to-focus” on a particular object when necessary to achieve as much parity between image sets as possible. Every photo presented here is straight out of camera and resized to 2500px on the long end at 72ppi. No editing has been done at all. So, how did both devices stack up? Well, let’s move onto my 100% subjective analysis.
Test 1 – The snapshot
As you can see in this first example, the iPhone 6 Plus put out a photo that had much more natural color and tone. The OnePlus One version does have rich tonality but the colors are punched way too far for my taste and there does seem to be a boost in clarity. Now, I can understand that there simply are lots of people who like this particular look. However, casting all judgements aside, it just seems like the iPhone puts out a much truer photo.
Test 2 – The ber dynamic range shot
My next test was to see how both devices handled shooting a scene that likely has the greatest dynamic range possible: straight into the sun. What’s interesting here is that I find myself wishing to have the best of both images. The iPhone does a superb job of handling the sky. The sun is appropriately represented and the blue sky is consistent and smooth. However, the shadows seem a bit muddy. Now, the OnePlus One handles the darker areas really well. There is plenty of detail and the colors look good. Unfortunately, it totally obliterates the sky and turns it into one of those awful HDR renditions that make purists reach for their pitchforks. So in this case, I feel that neither outperforms the other.
Test 3 – The blue sky shot
Now, this comparison does a perfect job of illustrating Apple’s stranglehold on mobile phone photography. If you watch the Apple Keynote where the iPhone 6 was announced, Apple Sr. VP of Worldwide Marketing, Phil Schiller, makes it a point to bring up how well the camera sensor handles noise reduction while also preserving blue skies. This was a hallmark test conducted because blue is one of the trickiest colors for digital camera sensors to manage. In this case, though, the iPhone 6 Plus just skewers the OnePlus One on all counts. It’s just a better photo all around.
Test 4 – The macro-ish shot
Next up, I wanted to see how both cameras compared with a macro-style shot. Neither camera has a specific macro mode but both do a very respectable job of focusing close up. I did run into a few instances when the iPhone abdicated to focusing at the center despite me touching the area to focus whereas the One always focused where I touched. However, once again, the iPhone 6 Plus puts out a much more natural looking image and handles highlights and shadows very nicely.
Test 5 – The 100% crop shot
My final test was comparing a set of images at 100% crop while overlaying the full image for reference. The iPhone does a much better job with wrangling in the bright spots of Mt. Hood while also doing an admirable job in keeping the sky noise-free. The One actually does a good job in presenting nice, warm tones throughout the foreground, however it falls pretty flat with preserving the details of the mountain and also introduces a ton of noise in the sky.
So there you have it.
My goal for this face off was not to extoll the virtues of one camera over the other. I don’t see a point in telling you whether one is better than the other because mobile phones and the platforms that they run on have become such a personal thing that it is really the responsibility of the individual to determine which one meets their needs best. In the context of this face off, though, the iPhone 6 Plus consistently provided me with images that I found very appealing. Which begs the question: if the only camera you have is your smartphone, shouldn’t that be the primary criteria for you? I hope this face off helps you decide.
Thanks for this, Brian. I have a 3-month old LG G3 that I’m considering swapping for the iPhone 6 just for the camera. The G3’s camera is good, but I’m always on the prowl, ya know? :) You’ve been most helpful in assisting me, thanks again.
Thank you for that, Michael!
I had the LG G3 for about a week before returning it, too. The screen was great and it had some really novel features but the battery life was abysmal. I was also turned off to the build quality. It just felt cheap compared to the One.
With that said, I feel that the iPhone had unparalleled build quality. It just feels amazing.
No waiting or lines here in Grand Junction. After handling both phones, bought the smaller 6. Shot a low light slomo video last night. Result better than expected. Love the zoomed display feature. The evolution keeps getting better.
nice article, but i’d be more interested to read it without the addition of turning on the hdr app on the android. if you’re going to compare apples to non-apples, don’t tweak the non-apple shots ahead of time. mike (just down the road in salem)
I thought about that, Mike… I really did. Ultimately, I opted to turn the HDR feature on because I felt it gave me more consistency and parity in my comparison. I felt that if I let Apple have its perceived advantage of using Auto HDR, then I should let the One play on the same field. However, I wouldn’t say that the One photos were tweaked any differently than the iPhone 6’s. Both have their own sensors and algorithms that do ‘something’ when the HDR mode in invoked, so I think it is a fair comparison for this particular environment.… Read more »
Hi Brian, thanks for your comparison!
But did you use ‘HDR mode’ on the One in Tests 4 and 5? Those photos look really strange and I’ve seen much better results from the One. Please take a look at these, for example:
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/content_link/bBgUniuoGAVIQDnqSTHP49mxJWEBwKzFNRJMS4grRQ2HmBdHOYu8X4W3j7BCBXBR
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/content_link/k5ak33n095HeItOoFg2AgfMKKJdfY7otF7DXE0AmhM9t8wrz73x5OH8oxdB2anHw
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/content_link/YVPO7pr9kuSDdsWBnwMmCnpnVR5m7z8p7WwuizREWr4c5Ipmu6XOYuF1MleJOl52
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/content_link/lXCYaFVkDkGxLCe81FHQgKdv1r8vjlNztghs1xrZLHchCDnBoKJJLHAoafVy5YkM
Have a nice weekend,
Jim
Hey Jim,
Yup – HDR Mode was used on all five tests. I didn’t deviate at all from the methodology that I wrote about in the article. While I know that so much of this is subjective and should obviously be taken with a grain of salt, I know that I conducted this experiment with integrity.
I also appreciate you linking to the photos but I’m getting a 403 error when clicking on each link. :(
A little misleading to say this is a comparison with Android. There’s lots of different Android phones with lots of different cameras and different camera software. Can’t see how you can pick one and say it represents them all.
I’m not sure why you would think this comparison would be misleading by me labeling it as Android. In fact, my goal was to make it as universally applicable as possible – which is why I used the Google Camera app as opposed to the stock camera app, as clearly indicated in the post. The Google Camera app is readily available to any Android phone running a compatible version of Android, so it is more accessible for users to test on their own. Now, I chose the OnePlus One because of the Android phones that I own (I have a… Read more »
Hello Brian,
This comparison seems a bit odd to me because Hdr mode in Google camera is just ugly – thats not a secret :)
Do that same comparison without Hdr mode and the One will outperform the iPhone. Just sayin ;)
Hi Brian,
Sorry for the bad links. Made a shared folder now that should work: http://goo.gl/n1ETp0
Have a nice weekend!