If you want to learn to make art, you should learn from artists. A couple of weeks ago I learned an important lesson by contrasting painters and photographers.

Painters do an activity called En Plein Air, which refers to painting in the open air; photographers would call it shooting on location. There’s this terrific contest in Logan, Utah requiring painters to have a blank canvas stamped Monday morning and then they have to submit finished work Wednesday morning as the kick off to the arts fair. The works they turn out in just two days are pretty incredible. A couple of years ago, they started a photography contest with the same rules (using metadata to verify the time constraints) and submitting to that contest has been one of the highlights of the year for me.

On Wednesday evening the winners for both photography and painting are announced at a reception with the hundreds of works hanging in a huge tent at the fair. Paintings hang in one half and photographs hang in the other. All the artists turn out to see what the competition created, and there is lots of discussion and camaraderie. I noticed a big difference between the photogs and the painters, however, as they looked at the pieces. Photographers looked at a picture, moved very close and examined the paper/pixels, then moved on to the next one, spending as long as twenty seconds looking at a picture, but five seconds was probably more average. Painters, on the other hand, stood looking at a painting for as much as a minute before moving closer to examine the technique. Then they stepped back and looked again. Then they turned to someone else and talked about the work. Then they went on to another image, but usually came back and looked at everything at least once more, truly considering those that caught their eye.
I think photographers should focus a little more and slow down. Spend more time looking at one image. Consider the artist’s intentions, the feelings an image evokes or depicts. Consider the composition and what makes it work–is it a simple rule of thirds? Are there leading lines that direct the eye? How are tonal values arranged to draw emphasis? What colors are important? Of course you can do this at art museums, but also do it in magazines, and 500px.com, and G+, and Pinterest. Spend more quality time looking at more pictures, and I bet you’ll end up spending more quality time making your pictures, too (both at time of capture at in post).
A word of caution: don’t be too hasty to be negatively critical. Photographers are prone to pick pictures apart on what’s wrong. I know I’m guilty! The painters I watched found the merits and moved on. I suppose if I’m as famous as Ansel Adams or Richard Avedon and have made as many important pictures I may finally have some worthwhile input on what might make someone else’s pictures better. Until then, I’ll try to slow down, shut up, and savor what I see.

NOTE: This approach is just one way of thinking… but it should help you experience photography in a different way.


Related topics

July 31, 2013

You might also like:

Thanks to our partners who make photofocus possible:

B&H – B&H is a world renowned supplier of all the gear photographers, videographers, and cinematographers need and want to create their very best work.

Skylum – Your photos, more beautiful in minutes. Makers of Luminar and Aurora HDR, Skylum adapts to your style and skill level. Check out Luminar 4’s unique sky replacement and portrait editing tools, now available. Save 42% off the retail price and get the Photofocus bundle for free!

Excire – Experience the best photo organizer for your photo library and discover your photos by color, subject — even people. Try the new Excire Foto application, or use Excire Search 2.0 as a plugin with Lightroom Classic.

Xpozer – Show off your photos and fill your walls with the Xpozer frame system. Xpozer makes it easy to switch out your photos in a matter of minutes! Check out the Xpozer Start-Pack, including a 16×24″ print and frame, plus $210 worth of bonuses, exclusive to Photofocus readers!

DNP Printers – DNP provides a full line of printers and solutions for retailers, event photographers and photo booth operators.

Illuminati – Get perfect exposure every time, with the new Illuminati IM-150 light and color meter.

Drobo – Drobo is the smartest storage solution in the world. Drobo is storage that protects data — photos, videos and everything else — from hard drive failure. Save 10% with the coupon code PHOTOFOCUS.