• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Becoming a Better Drone Pilot: Brother AirScouter WD-300C Head-mounted Display Review
  • The Traveling Photographer: Photographing People: Guidelines
  • Mirrorless Camera Maniac: Panasonic Leica 200mm f/2.8 Offers Superb Build Quality & Reach
  • The Vello BG-N19 Battery Grip for Nikon D850
  • My First Aurora HDR 2018 Experience

Photofocus

education and inspiration for visual storytellers

Menu
  • Blog
  • Photo
    • Shooting
    • Gear
    • Lighting
    • Photography
    • Close
  • Video
    • Shooting
    • Gear
    • Lighting
    • Cinematography
    • Close
  • Learn
    • Maximize Lightroom
    • HDR
    • Video
    • Lightroom
    • Photoshop
    • Close
  • Gear Guides
    • Bird Photography
    • The Ultimate GoPro Kit
    • Close
  • Business
  • Inspiration
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Audio Podcasts
    • Video Podcasts
    • Close
  • Software
  • Contests

Gear Review: NiSi Medium GND 100x150mm Filter

Photofocus Team 02/08/2018 0

Editor’s note: This is a guest Post by Ugo Cei. See his work right here.

In recent times I haven’t been making much use of filters in my photography. I would occasionally use a polarizer and that’s all. As a consequence, when faced with landscape scenes with a lot of contrast, like when the sky is bright, but the ground is in shade, I would normally resort to bracketing and then merging the resulting shots to HDR or doing some kind of blending.

Graduated Neutral Density (GND) Filters

When creating HDR photos, I always strive to produce natural looking results but, depending on the scene, my attempts are not always successful. Because of this, and because at this point in time I am trying to spend less time at the computer and to get more photos right in camera, I resolved to bring back from retirement my old Lee Filters rectangular, hard GND filter.

Doing so reminded me of why I haven’t been using it much at all. For one thing, a hard GND (Graduated Neutral Density) presents an abrupt transition between its clear and dark parts and this makes it only suitable for scenes where the horizon is flat. If you have mountains above its line, they will be too dark. If there are any objects, like trees, crossing the horizon’s line, the will be darker at the top. This negates all the benefits of using a GND filter.

Additionally, I find that precise placement of the filter so that it matches the skyline to be quite difficult at times, creating unnatural transitions between the ground and the sky.

Another reason why I haven’t been using this filter is that it’s plastic and prone to scratching. As a matter of fact, even though I’ve always handled it very carefully, it’s all scratched. I’m not sure the scratches would be visible in photos, but I know they affect image quality when shooting straight into the sun, something I tend to do frequently.

So I was looking for a replacement when a friend suggested that I try the new “medium” GND filters from NiSi. As the name says, a medium GND filter has a transition between the dark and light areas that is halfway between the abrupt one provided by hard GNDs and the very gradual one provided by soft GNDs. NiSi says it is recommended for images that feature buildings, mountains, and other small elements that protrude into the skyline.

So I ordered a 100x150mm medium GND filter with a 0.9 density (3 stops) and brought it with me on my most recent trip. I didn’t need a holder because this filter is the same size as my old Lee one, so I knew I could reuse the old system with the new filter.

How Good Is It Optically?

This is not a scientific test done in the lab, but I tried to measure some characteristics of the filter with as much accuracy as I could. I especially wanted to answer the following questions:

  • Is the filter color-neutral or does it introduce undesirable color casts?
  • Does placing the filter in front of a lens decrease its sharpness?
  • Does the filter create flare or ghosting when shooting into strong light sources?
  • How accurate is it?
  • After having applied the proverbial two grains of salt, here are my conclusions.

Color Neutrality

I tested for the presence of color casts by photographing a white sheet of paper, with or without the filter. White balance was set based on the sheet itself under sunlight. I then measured the RGB values of the resulting images using the color picker in Adobe Lightroom in various parts of the images.

Discrepancies between the channels measured to less than 1%, so I can say with confidence that the NiSi filter is remarkably neutral and doesn’t introduce any color casts.

On the left: with the filter. On the right: without the filter.

Sharpness

I can’t see any degradation of image sharpness when the filter is mounted.

On the left: with the filter. On the right: without the filter. 200% enlargement. Shot on a Fujifilm X-T2 with the Fujinon XF 16-55mm F2.8 R LM WR lens.

Accuracy

I did this test by photographing a white sheet of paper with and without the filter, using the same settings (0.8s at f/5.6, ISO 200). The filter was positioned so that only its darkest portion covered the field of view.

I imported both files into Adobe Lightroom, increased exposure on the filtered image by 3.0 and compared RGB readings in the center of both. The image taken with the filter is slightly darker than the one without: RGB values were around 77% for the former and 81% for the latter.

While this is clearly not a very precise measurement, I would say that the density of the NiSi filter density is remarkably close to the 3 stops advertised.

On the left: with the filter. On the right: without the filter.

How Useful Is It?

I bought this filter because I thought it would be more useful than either a hard- or a soft-GND, on the average. Of course, no amount of gradation can be perfect for all situations, so it would arguably be best to have a hard-, a soft-, and a medium-GND in one’s bag. Maybe it would be even better to have filters with densities of 2, 3, and 4 stops to cover a wider range of lighting imbalances. Considering that this filter alone cost me about $150, getting 9 of them is out of the discussion, so I decided to go for a medium gradation and a medium density, knowing it wouldn’t always be a perfect match.

Here’s an example of a scene where one might want to use such a filter. First, a photo was taken without the use of any filters. In order to maintain enough detail in the shadow, the sky on the left had to be overexposed to the point of clipping the highlights.

No GND

The same scene, but now using the GND filter. The sky is darker and more colorful, with no clipping, while exposure on the ground is pretty much the same. There is no hard edge across the building on the right.

With GND

In this case, it would have been hard to obtain a similar effect in post-processing, for example using a graduated filter adjustment in Adobe Lightroom. Even when highlights can be recovered, I believe it is much better to get a photo right in camera, when possible.

When the range of light in the scene exceeds the camera’s dynamic range, a GND filter can make the difference between a photo bound for the trashcan and a perfectly exposed one.

Here’s the final image, after having applied some tonal adjustments in Adobe Lightroom.

Conclusions

Having had this NiSi Medium GND filter for a short time, it’s too early for me to draw conclusions about its usefulness in the long run. I can already see that it’s going to get more use than my old hard gradient filter, since I rarely get to shoot scenes with a clean horizon, but how much use it will actually get still remains to be seen. For sure, I am confident that it won’t degrade my photos in any way, so I can use it any time I feel like it makes my life easier.

 

Ugo Cei is a fine-art travel and landscape photographer from Italy. If you were to ask him what he does, he would say that he is an educator who helps photography enthusiasts sharpen their skills, so that they can take amazing pictures. He does this in various ways. First of all, by providing a wealth of free content on his website. He also leads photography tours and workshops to some cool destinations, including Oman, Venice, Milan, Cinque Terre, and Sardinia. He co-hosts and publishes a weekly podcast about travel photography, The Traveling Image Makers. Every week, they pick the brains of famous and not-so-famous travel photographers to learn what it means to travel for the love of photography and photograph for the love of travel.

  • About
  • Latest Posts

Photofocus Team

Latest posts by Photofocus Team (see all)

  • Flickr is Bought by SmugMug - April 20, 2018
  • Inspiration Can Strike Anywhere (Or How I Made the Most Viewed Photos of My Career) - April 12, 2018
  • Skylum Software Offers Free Hands-On Shooting Lab at Shutterfest - March 22, 2018

Categories: Photography Reviews Tags: density filter GND graduated HDR landscape Lee Filter neutral NiSi polarizer sunrise sunset

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Google
  • Email
  • Print
 

You May Also Like:

Please Support Our Partners:

Datacolor Spyder – There is no better time to enhance your capabilities in color management and create outstanding images. Calibrating your display is the first step to ensuring your prints accurately match what you see on your screen.

Luminar – Meet the world’s first photo editor that adapts to your style & skill level. Luminar is the supercharged photo software that makes complex editing easy & enjoyable.

MPB.com – We buy, sell and trade used camera equipment with custom-designed technology, built to solve the challenges of peer to peer transactions. Our rapidly growing marketplace is available in the UK, US and EU countries. Build a camera setup that's right for you with MPB.

Platypod – Platypod Pro LLC makes the world's most compact mini tripod bases for photographers. Inspired by the duck-billed platypus, an animal with flat and broad feet, we designed our camera supports to be ideal for low-angle shots and situations where traditional tripods are cumbersome or impractical.

Perfectly Clear Complete – Built for precision. Made for beauty. Perfectly Clear has mastered the science of intelligent image correction - creating superior quality photos in record time, so you can get back to doing what you really love...in no time. Special Photofocus deal here.

HDR Learning Center – Check out new ways to use High Dynamic Range photography to make compelling images. Free tutorials and posts to get results. Produced in partnership with HDRsoft.

Adobe Portfolio – Beautifully Simple Creative Portfolio Websites are a snap to build. Try Adobe Portfolio, a tool to build your own personalized website in minutes, available to Creative Cloud subscribers today https://www.myportfolio.com.

ThinkTAP – New online education for photographers by working professionals. Be one of the first 50 people to buy our new time-lapse training for only $99 (that’s 60% off); use the code TL50.

Reader Interactions

Comment Policy: Vigorous discussion is welcome. Please use your real names and respect one another.

Share Your Thoughts Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Our eBooks

  • Develop Great Images in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (Scribd | iBooks)
  • The Basic Beginner’s Guide to Photography Light & Exposure (iBooks)
  • Secrets of HDR (iBooks)
  • 72 Essays on Photography (iBooks | Amazon)

Footer

Photofocus

Regardless of the type of photography you focus on, Photofocus is here as a helpful and educational resource for the aspiring and professional photographer. Our goal is to assist in your success as an artist.

Advertise on Photofocus

Our eBooks

  • Develop Great Images in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (Scribd | iBooks)
  • The Basic Beginner’s Guide to Photography Light & Exposure (iBooks)
  • Secrets of HDR (iBooks)
  • 72 Essays on Photography (iBooks | Amazon)

Follow Us On Twitter

Follow @photofocus
Follow @scottbourne
Follow @rhedpixel
Follow @rodharlan
Follow @davecross
Follow @lightroomers
Follow @JoeMcNallyPhoto
Follow @Matthew_JordanS
© 2018 Photofocus · All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Advertise
    • Marketing Kit
  • Authors
    • The Publisher
    • The Founder
  • Contact Us
  • Legal
    • Contests
    • FTC Disclosures
    • Review Guidelines
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.