• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Becoming a Better Drone Pilot: Brother AirScouter WD-300C Head-mounted Display Review
  • The Traveling Photographer: Photographing People: Guidelines
  • Mirrorless Camera Maniac: Panasonic Leica 200mm f/2.8 Offers Superb Build Quality & Reach
  • The Vello BG-N19 Battery Grip for Nikon D850
  • My First Aurora HDR 2018 Experience

Photofocus

education and inspiration for visual storytellers

Menu
  • Blog
  • Photo
    • Shooting
    • Gear
    • Lighting
    • Photography
    • Close
  • Video
    • Shooting
    • Gear
    • Lighting
    • Cinematography
    • Close
  • Learn
    • Maximize Lightroom
    • HDR
    • Video
    • Lightroom
    • Photoshop
    • Close
  • Gear Guides
    • Bird Photography
    • The Ultimate GoPro Kit
    • Close
  • Business
  • Inspiration
  • News
  • Podcasts
    • Audio Podcasts
    • Video Podcasts
    • Close
  • Software
  • Contests

Photo Book Reviews #27 – Hareker’s One Room Schoolhouses

Scott Bourne 10/26/2008 0

Hareker’s One Room Schoolhouses : Visions of an Iowa Icon

Author: Michael P. Harker

Publisher: University of Iowa Press

Review by Conrad J. Obregon

There is a type of traditional photograph that I think of as “confrontational”. The subject seems to present itself directly, with little effort to make us like it. Nothing is offered to make us care for the subject: no little bit of softening; or touching at a memory; or suggestion that something worth loving exists, or might have existed, within. If we love such a confrontational picture, it is because of what we bring to it; because of the connotations that we carry in our mind rather then the denotation of the photographer. If we love such a picture, it may be in spite of itself.

The pictures of the one-room schoolhouses that Michael Harker presents in these images are confrontational. The one-room schoolhouses are photographed without any mellowing influence. Instead, many of them are shot from a three-quarters angle so that one side appears in sunlight and another in shade. This in turn leads to a harsh and unmitigated contrast that is more likely to occupy the viewer’s mind than thoughts about what once went on inside the schoolhouses. Often someone’s picture of an old school building will lead us to wonder what life was like in its heyday, full of children and community. But these pictures of old schoolhouses reminded me only of the impermanence of what man creates.

Only in the few pictures of the interiors of a few of the schools do we think of the living who sat at the desks and prepared themselves to learn the world. Only then do we think that Paul Theobold, whose essay is included, might be right to suggest that we may have lost something of value when we switched from the one-room schoolhouse to the regional campus.

Although the black and white images presented here have a superficial resemblance to the images in the artist’s earlier book “Harker’s Barns”, a close reading of the two will show the differences. Both the structures and the angles of view of the different barns varied more than here. Some were still working, as indicated by the cattle or hay bales in the scene, even though they were starting to run down. Others showed us their context. Tonalities supported the overall feeling. Sometimes even the abandoned barns made us feel that something important had gone on there, and even, that perhaps they deserved a well-earned rest.

I’m certain there are people who find confrontational subjects attractive. There are also folks who so love these old schoolhouses that the approach of the photographer will not be material and these folks will find this volume interesting. But for me, Harker’s one-room schoolhouses remind me more of a disinterested archeology then of a work of love. Comparing the two books will help readers understand a great deal about the nature of photography.
_______________

  • About
  • Latest Posts
Follow Me:

Scott Bourne

Founder at Photofocus
Founder of Photofocus.com. Professional photographer. Author. Speaker.
Follow Me:

Latest posts by Scott Bourne (see all)

  • Thanks For The Memories - March 31, 2017
  • Alaska Eagle Photography Diary 2017 – Part 3 - March 29, 2017
  • Perfectly Clear Complete Version 3.0 – A Quick Look - March 29, 2017

Categories: Shooting Tags: book review

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Google
  • Email
  • Print
 

You May Also Like:

Please Support Our Partners:

Datacolor Spyder – There is no better time to enhance your capabilities in color management and create outstanding images. Calibrating your display is the first step to ensuring your prints accurately match what you see on your screen.

Luminar – Meet the world’s first photo editor that adapts to your style & skill level. Luminar is the supercharged photo software that makes complex editing easy & enjoyable.

MPB.com – We buy, sell and trade used camera equipment with custom-designed technology, built to solve the challenges of peer to peer transactions. Our rapidly growing marketplace is available in the UK, US and EU countries. Build a camera setup that's right for you with MPB.

Platypod – Platypod Pro LLC makes the world's most compact mini tripod bases for photographers. Inspired by the duck-billed platypus, an animal with flat and broad feet, we designed our camera supports to be ideal for low-angle shots and situations where traditional tripods are cumbersome or impractical.

Perfectly Clear Complete – Built for precision. Made for beauty. Perfectly Clear has mastered the science of intelligent image correction - creating superior quality photos in record time, so you can get back to doing what you really love...in no time. Special Photofocus deal here.

HDR Learning Center – Check out new ways to use High Dynamic Range photography to make compelling images. Free tutorials and posts to get results. Produced in partnership with HDRsoft.

Adobe Portfolio – Beautifully Simple Creative Portfolio Websites are a snap to build. Try Adobe Portfolio, a tool to build your own personalized website in minutes, available to Creative Cloud subscribers today https://www.myportfolio.com.

ThinkTAP – New online education for photographers by working professionals. Be one of the first 50 people to buy our new time-lapse training for only $99 (that’s 60% off); use the code TL50.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Quin says

    October 28, 2008 at 4:32 pm

    Interesting book. At the risk of doing a plug, we’ve been running an art gallery out of a one room schoolhouse for 26 years. It was built in 1859 and served as a schoolhouse for about a hundred years. It’s a cool space, and if it is haunted, the ghosts have always been friendly. 😉 Never made a peep even when I had a studio and lived in the building for a year.
    There’s some cool grafitti carved into the bricks by kids over the last century and a half…and sometime I have to photgraph it all.
    http://www.marcbarrie.com/gallery.htm

     
    Reply

Comment Policy: Vigorous discussion is welcome. Please use your real names and respect one another.

Share Your Thoughts Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Our eBooks

  • Develop Great Images in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (Scribd | iBooks)
  • The Basic Beginner’s Guide to Photography Light & Exposure (iBooks)
  • Secrets of HDR (iBooks)
  • 72 Essays on Photography (iBooks | Amazon)

Footer

Photofocus

Regardless of the type of photography you focus on, Photofocus is here as a helpful and educational resource for the aspiring and professional photographer. Our goal is to assist in your success as an artist.

Advertise on Photofocus

Our eBooks

  • Develop Great Images in Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (Scribd | iBooks)
  • The Basic Beginner’s Guide to Photography Light & Exposure (iBooks)
  • Secrets of HDR (iBooks)
  • 72 Essays on Photography (iBooks | Amazon)

Follow Us On Twitter

Follow @photofocus
Follow @scottbourne
Follow @rhedpixel
Follow @rodharlan
Follow @davecross
Follow @lightroomers
Follow @JoeMcNallyPhoto
Follow @Matthew_JordanS
© 2018 Photofocus · All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Advertise
    • Marketing Kit
  • Authors
    • The Publisher
    • The Founder
  • Contact Us
  • Legal
    • Contests
    • FTC Disclosures
    • Review Guidelines
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.