The Photograph: Composition & Color Design by Harald Mante
Publisher: Rocky Nook
Review by Conrad J. Obregon
Rocky Nook is a relatively new entrant into the field of photography publications. One of the niches that it has taken aim on is the translation of books into English that appear in European languages. One might think that in a global culture, where a digital camera is the same in Germany as in the United States, and Lightroom has the same interface in both countries, there would be little room for variation in theory, but this book seems to prove that thesis incorrect.
While I have not read every book on photographic composition in the English language, the theories of composition presented by Mante differ from most that I’ve encountered. When discussing composition, most authors speak about the rule of thirds, or where to put the horizon in a picture, or simplification. Mante on the other hand, discusses the importance of the point, or multiple points, or lines or shapes, or ground and field, or contrast. (At least one other author, Richard Zakia, has tried to deal with these same concepts, but his book is too idiosyncratic to recommend.)
The chapters of the book are organized to present a single concept, like a line of points, with text, several illustrative photographs, and diagrams. Frequently one is required to flip back and forth between text, photograph and diagram. The photographs by Mante are quite beautiful, although they bear a close resemblance to the self-referential. By that I mean that the content explicated by the form is the form itself. For example, those familiar with Albers color squares recognize that the content is the perception created by placing certain colors in proximity to each other. Mante’s photograph of a purple wall with a green beam in it is not about the wall, but rather about the relation of purple and green. Most current photography seems to be far more about the content, with technique explicating the content, then Mante’s pictures and instruction. Mante doesn’t disdain content. In fact he recognizes its primacy. But this is a book about form, and that’s what the photographs emphasize.
The text is quite difficult reading being quite dry and technical, and I suspect that many photographers will not be interested in following this theoretical line of the development of composition. Yet for those photographers who are given to a more technical, cerebral approach to the creation of images, this material, because of its different approach, may provide new insights into composition. It will also appeal to photographers who are searching for an approach to design different from the common wisdom.
Even though I was willing to consider a new way of looking at composition, I found that Mante stopped just short of where I wanted him to go. His final thesis seems to be that the photographer should direct the viewer to content through contrast in design. But I would have liked for him to explain how particular forms of contrast can direct the viewer’s inner eye to the photographer’s vision, or how “technique is discovery”. Still, the approach to design holds so much promise for a new way to compose photographs that I will try to apply Mante’s teachings to my own work.
In summery, if you are a photographer who is willing to consider broad theory in an effort to enhance the composition of your photographs and are willing to risk an investment of your time that may or may not be productive, this is a book for you.
Latest posts by Scott Bourne (see all)
- What’s In My Micro Four Thirds Bag? - August 27, 2016
- The Seven Best Lenses Ever Made (For Mirrorless Cameras) - August 22, 2016
- Panasonic 12mm f/1.4 ASPH Leica DG SUMMILUX First Look - August 19, 2016